AMC Clinicals Vs PESCI Exam: What To Choose?

Oct 24, 2024 3 min read
AMC Clinicals Vs PESCI Exam

Are you an international medical graduate (IMG) who has recently passed the AMC Part 1 (MCQ) exam and is wondering what your next step should be? IMGs have different options after passing AMC 1, such as AMC Clinicals or PESCI.

Deciding between the AMC Clinical Exam and the PESCI (Pre-Employment Structured Clinical Interview) can be challenging, but it’s a crucial decision that shapes your pathway to practise in Australia. Both exams evaluate clinical skills, yet they serve different purposes and lead to distinct career outcomes. 

This blog will break down the key differences between these assessments, helping you choose the right path based on your career aspirations and professional goals.

Purpose of the Exams

AMC Clinical Exam: The Australian Medical Council (AMC) Clinical Exam is the second part of the AMC exam pathway. Its primary goal is to assess the clinical competency of IMGs to ensure they meet Australian healthcare standards. This exam evaluates a doctor’s ability to manage various clinical situations, ensuring they possess the necessary skills to provide safe and effective patient care in Australia.
PESCI (Pre-Employment Structured Clinical Interview): PESCI is designed for IMGs who have already secured a specific job offer in Australia. It is used to assess whether the IMG is suitable for the particular role they will be performing, ensuring they have the right clinical and professional skills for that specific job. This exam focuses more on the ability to work in a specific environment rather than general clinical competency.

Eligibility and Registration Outcomes

AMC Clinical Exam

  • IMGs must pass the AMC MCQ exam before becoming eligible for the AMC Clinical Exam.
  • Passing the AMC Clinical Exam is essential for obtaining general registration in Australia.
  • General registration allows doctors to practice independently in various roles and locations across Australia.

PESCI

  • IMGs must pass the AMC MCQ exam to be eligible for PESCI.
  • IMGs should have three years of experience.
  • PESCI is for IMGs applying for limited registration, typically linked to a specific job offer. PESCI grants limited registration, meaning doctors can only work in the specific role they were assessed for without general registration.

Assessment Structure and Format

AMC Clinical Exam

Format: The AMC Clinical Exam is an Objective Structured Clinical Examination (OSCE) comprising 16 scenarios. These scenarios test a doctor’s clinical decision-making, communication skills, and procedural abilities across disciplines like medicine, surgery, paediatrics, obstetrics, and psychiatry.

Focus: The exam tests general clinical skills applicable across various settings, ensuring that IMGs can deliver patient care that aligns with Australian standards. It evaluates patient history-taking, physical examinations, diagnosis, management, and communication skills.

PESCI

Format: PESCI is a structured clinical interview conducted by a panel. The panel assesses the IMG’s clinical and professional skills based on role-play scenarios, case discussions, and questions about the job they are applying for.

Focus: It assesses whether the IMG is suitable for a specific job, focusing on their ability to handle real-life clinical situations in the environment they will be working in. It’s less about general medical competence and more about job-specific performance.

Costs

AMC Clinical Exam: The AMC Clinical Exam costs around AUD 4,391, not including preparation resources or travel expenses for the exam location.

PESCI: PESCI fees range from AUD 2,000 to AUD 4,000, depending on the provider. This can be more cost-effective for doctors who have a clear job offer.

Job Flexibility and Career Opportunities

AMC Clinical Exam

Passing the AMC Clinical Exam allows IMGs to apply for general registration, offering more career flexibility. Doctors can apply for various roles in public hospitals, private practices, and other healthcare settings across Australia.

With general registration, doctors are not tied to a specific job and can practice independently, which opens up long-term career growth and broader job opportunities.

PESCI 

PESCI leads to limited registration tied to the specific position for which the IMG was assessed. This means the doctor must work under supervision and can only practice in the role they were hired for.

While PESCI allows for quicker employment, especially in workforce shortage areas, it does not provide the same job flexibility as the AMC Clinical pathway. Further assessments may be needed to obtain general registration later.

Which Path Should You Choose?

AMC Clinical Pathway: If you seek long-term career opportunities and independence in Australia, the AMC Clinical pathway is the way to go. While it may take longer and require more comprehensive preparation, passing the AMC Clinicals allows for broader job opportunities and career mobility across the country.

If you choose this, enrol in the best AMC Clinical Preparation Course to pass the AMC 2 on the first attempt.

PESCI Pathway: If you have already secured a job offer in a specific role and want to start working quickly, the PESCI pathway may be the better choice. However, it limits your ability to move freely between jobs, and further steps will be needed for general registration in the future.

Read More About the Complete Guide To The Pre-employment Structured Clinical Interview (PESCI) for IMGs

Criteria

AMC Clinical Exam

PESCI 

PurposeAssesses general clinical skills for medical practice in AustraliaEvaluates suitability for a specific job role in Australia
EligibilityRequires passing AMC Part 1 (MCQ)Requires passing AMC Part 1 (MCQ), having 3 years of work experience and a job offer in Australia
Structure16 OSCE scenarios covering multiple disciplinesInterview with role-play and job-specific cases
FocusTests overall clinical competencyFocuses on role-specific skills
CostAUD 4,391AUD 2,000 to AUD 4,000
Job FlexibilityBroad job options across AustraliaLimited to the assessed role
Best ForIMGs seeking career flexibility in AustraliaIMGs with a secured job looking for quick entry

Final Words

Both the AMC Clinical and PESCI exams are crucial assessments for IMGs aspiring to practice in Australia, but they serve different purposes. 

The AMC Clinical Exam is a more comprehensive test of general medical competency, leading to broader job opportunities and general registration. On the other hand, PESCI is job-specific and provides a quicker route to limited registration for a particular role. 

Choosing the correct pathway depends on your career goals, job offers, and long-term plans in Australia. Fill out this form for free one-on-one counselling with our expert. 

Dr. Indu K
Dr. Indu K
about the author

Dr. Indu K is a dentist with one year of clinical experience. She seamlessly transitioned into content writing three years ago. Her passion lies in making complex medical information accessible to everyone. She uses her unique blend of medical knowledge and exceptional writing skills to bridge the gap between healthcare and the general audience.